Cozy Up Your Glass: 4 Autumn Herbal Mocktails for Fall & Holiday Gatherings

Melanie May

As the weather cools down and autumn gatherings move indoors, entertaining trends are shifting. More hostesses, dinner guests, and partygoers are embracing mindful drinking—looking for elevated, low-sugar, non-alcoholic drinks that feel festive and luxurious without the morning hangover.

Enter cold-brew craft teas. Herbal and spiced tea blends make a complex, aromatic base for fall spritzers, warm holiday punches, and cozy evening mocktails.

Whether you are hosting Thanksgiving dinner, a cozy Friendsgiving, or looking for a relaxing nightcap, here are four autumn-inspired mocktail recipes featuring seasonal spice blends to elevate your cozy holiday hosting.

1. The Fireside Apple Butter Spritz

Rich apple notes combined with cinnamon and autumn spices make this crisp spritzer an ideal welcome drink for autumn guests.

Base Tea: Apple Butter Herbal (or try our Apple Butter Green for a slight caffeinated kick)

Flavor Profile: Warm baked orchard fruit, spiced cinnamon, and bubbly citrus

Ingredients (Single Serving)

4 oz concentrated Apple Butter Herbal tea (chilled)

2 oz fresh sparkling apple cider or ginger beer

¼ oz fresh lemon juice

Cinnamon stick & apple fan for garnish

How to Prepare

  1. Steep 2 tablespoons of Apple Butter Herbal tea in 6 oz of hot water for 7–10 minutes to create a strong syrup-like concentrate. Strain and let cool.

  2. Fill a wine glass or goblet with fresh ice.

  3. Combine the tea concentrate and lemon juice, then top with sparkling cider or ginger beer.

  4. Garnish with a fresh apple slice and a cinnamon stick stirrer.

2. Spiced Velvet Pumpkin Spice Oolong Highball

For lovers of decadent autumn flavors, this recipe blends smooth tea tannins with creamy pumpkin sweetness for a sophisticated dessert-style mocktail.

Base Tea: Pumpkin Spice Brulee Oolong

Flavor Profile: Creamy toasted vanilla, warm pumpkin pie spices, and roasted oolong notes

Ingredients (Single Serving)

4 oz chilled Pumpkin Spice Brulee Oolong

1 oz oat milk or cream

½ oz maple syrup

Pinch of fresh nutmeg or pumpkin pie spice

How to Prepare

  1. Brew Pumpkin Spice Brulee Oolong at 195°F for 4–5 minutes, strain, and chill completely.

  2. In a cocktail shaker with ice, combine the chilled oolong tea and maple syrup.

  3. Shake vigorously and strain into a tall highball glass filled with ice.

  4. Gently float the oat milk on top to create a layered effect, then dust with fresh nutmeg.

3. Warm Zero-Proof Mulled “Wine” Punch

Nothing says the holidays like the aroma of simmering mulled spice filling the home. This blend offers all the rich hibiscus berry depth and warming spices of traditional mulled wine—completely alcohol-free.

Base Tea: Mulled Wine Herbal

Flavor Profile: Tart hibiscus, rich clove, star anise, and citrus orange peel

Ingredients (Double serving)

16 oz brewed Mulled Wine Herbal tea

8 oz tart cherry or pomegranate juice

1 orange, sliced into rounds

2 star anise pods & 2 cinnamon sticks

How to Prepare

  1. In a small pot or slow cooker, simmer the Mulled Wine Herbal tea with tart cherry juice, orange slices, star anise, and cinnamon sticks on low heat for 15–20 minutes.

  2. Ladle into glass mugs or heat-safe punch glasses.

  3. Garnish with a floating orange wheel studded with cloves.

4. Pistachio Cream Nightcap

A silky, nutty after-dinner sip that feels like liquid dessert while keeping caffeine light and gentle.

Base Tea: Pistachio Pu’erh 

Flavor Profile: Earthy, rich, subtly sweet, and nutty

Ingredients (Single Serving)

4 oz concentrated Pistachio Pu’erh

1 oz warm steamed milk or almond milk

Drizzle of honey or agave

How to Prepare

  1. Steep the Pistachio Pu’erh in hot water for 5 minutes.

  2. Stir in honey and pour into a small glass mug.

  3. Top with lightly frothed warm milk for a comforting bedtime ritual.

Unsure Which Spice Profile Suits Your Palate?

Experimenting with tea mocktails is all about finding your perfect balance of fruit, spice, and sweetness. If you want to sample our autumn blends before stocking your pantry for holiday hosting, try our single-serving sample sizes of Apple Butter and Pistachio Pu’erh. They are the perfect portion size to craft your first batch of seasonal mocktails!

Pro Tip: Hosting a crowd? Easily double or triple any of these recipes in a pitcher or slow cooker!

0
Added to cart